Published Online:https://doi.org/10.5465/amj.2015.0416

Why would an organization pursue membership in an organizational category, yet forego opportunities to subsequently promote that membership? Drawing on prior research, we develop a theoretical model that distinguishes between basic and subordinate categories and highlights how organizations may differ in their promotion of the same subordinate category. We hypothesize that a subordinate category’s contextual distinctiveness within different basic categories increases promotion, and that these effects are amplified in relatively larger subordinate category peer groups. To test our hypotheses, we developed a proprietary web-based software toolset and gathered textual and graphical data regarding B Corporations’ web-based promotion of their certification. We supplemented our statistical analysis with interviews of Certified B Corporation entrepreneurs and executives. Our findings challenge prior assumptions about the causes of promotional forbearance, while extending our understanding of category distinctiveness within contexts as well as sources of intra-category variation.

REFERENCES

  • Albert S., Whetten D. A. 1985. Organizational identity. Research in Organizational Behavior, 7: 263–295. Google Scholar
  • Ansari S. M., Fiss P. C., Zajac E. J. 2010. Made to fit: How practices vary as they diffuse. Academy of Management Review, 35: 67–92.LinkGoogle Scholar
  • Besharov M. L., Smith W. K. 2014. Multiple institutional logics in organizations: Explaining their varied nature and implications. Academy of Management Review, 39: 364–381.LinkGoogle Scholar
  • Bucklin R. E., Sismeiro C. 2003. A model of web site browsing behavior estimated on clickstream data. JMR, Journal of Marketing Research, 40: 249–267. Google Scholar
  • Cameron A. C., Trivedi P. K. 2013. Regression analysis of count data (2nd edn). New York: Cambridge University Press. Google Scholar
  • Cao K., Gehman J., Grimes M. G. 2017. Standing out and fitting in: Charting the emergence of Certified B Corporations by industry and region. In Katz J. A.Corbett A. C. (Eds.), Hybrid ventures: Perspectives and approaches to blended value entrepreneurship. Advances in Entrepreneurship, Firm Emergence and Growth, vol. 19: 1–38. Bingley, UK: Emerald. Google Scholar
  • Carlos W. C., Lewis B. W. 2017. Strategic silence: Withholding certification status as a hypocrisy avoidance tactic. Administrative Science Quarterly, 1839217695089. Google Scholar
  • Chatterji A. K., Levine D. I., Toffel M. W. 2009. How well do social ratings actually measure corporate social responsibility? Journal of Economics & Management Strategy, 18: 125–169. Google Scholar
  • Cohen J., Cohen P., West S. G., Aiken L. S. 2003. Applied multiple regression/correlation analysis for the behavioral sciences (3rd edn). Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum. Google Scholar
  • Colyvas J. A., Jonsson S. 2011. Ubiquity and legitimacy: Disentangling diffusion and institutionalization. Sociological Theory, 29: 27–53. Google Scholar
  • Czarniawska B. 2008. Alterity/identity interplay in image construction. In Barry D.Hansen H. (Eds.), The Sage handbook of new approaches in management and organization: 49–62. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Google Scholar
  • Deephouse D. L. 1999. To be different, or to be the same? It’s a question (and theory) of strategic balance. Strategic Management Journal, 20: 147–166. Google Scholar
  • Deephouse D. L., Bundy J., Tost L. P., Suchman M. C. 2017. Organizational legitimacy: Six key questions. In Greenwood R.Oliver C.Lawrence T. B.Meyer R. E. (Eds.), The Sage handbook of organizational institutionalism (2nd edn): 27–54. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Google Scholar
  • Delmas M. A., Etzion D., Nairn-Birch N. 2013. Triangulating environmental performance: What do corporate social responsibility ratings really capture? The Academy of Management Perspectives, 27: 255–267.LinkGoogle Scholar
  • Delmas M. A., Grant L. E. 2014. Eco-labeling strategies and price-premium: The wine industry puzzle. Business & Society, 53: 6–44. Google Scholar
  • Delmas M., Montiel I. 2008. The diffusion of voluntary international management standards: Responsible care, ISO 9000, and ISO 14001 in the chemical industry. Policy Studies Journal: the Journal of the Policy Studies Organization, 36: 65–93. Google Scholar
  • Douglas M. 1986. How institutions think. Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press. Google Scholar
  • Durand R., Paolella L. 2013. Category stretching: Reorienting research on categories in strategy, entrepreneurship, and organization theory. Journal of Management Studies, 50: 1100–1123. Google Scholar
  • Durand R., Vergne J.-P. 2015. Asset divestment as a response to media attacks in stigmatized industries. Strategic Management Journal, 36: 1205–1223. Google Scholar
  • Echambadi R., Hess J. D. 2007. Mean-centering does not alleviate collinearity problems in moderated multiple regression models. Marketing Science, 26: 438–445. Google Scholar
  • Elsbach K. D., Bhattacharya C. B. 2001. Defining who you are by what you’re not: Organizational disidentification and the national rifle association. Organization Science, 12: 393–413. Google Scholar
  • Garud R., Gehman J. 2012. Metatheoretical perspectives on sustainability journeys: Evolutionary, relational and durational. Research Policy, 41: 980–995. Google Scholar
  • Garud R., Gehman J., Giuliani A. P. 2014. Contextualizing entrepreneurial innovation: A narrative perspective. Research Policy, 43: 1177–1188. Google Scholar
  • Garud R., Gehman J., Karnøe P. 2010. Categorization by association: Nuclear technology and emission-free electricity. In Sine W. D.David R. J. (Eds.), Institutions and entrepreneurship. Research in the Sociology of Work, vol. 21: 51–93. Bingley, UK: Emerald. Google Scholar
  • Garud R., Schildt H. A., Lant T. K. 2014. Entrepreneurial storytelling, future expectations, and the paradox of legitimacy. Organization Science, 25: 1479–1492. Google Scholar
  • Gehman J., Treviño L. K., Garud R. 2013. Values work: A process study of the emergence and performance of organizational values practices. Academy of Management Journal, 56: 84–112.LinkGoogle Scholar
  • Giorgi S., Lockwood C., Glynn M. A. 2015. The many faces of culture: Making sense of 30 years of research on culture in organization studies. The Academy of Management Annals, 9: 1–54.LinkGoogle Scholar
  • Glynn M. A., Abzug R. 2002. Institutionalizing identity: Symbolic isomorphism and organizational names. Academy of Management Journal, 45: 267–280.LinkGoogle Scholar
  • Glynn M. A., Navis C. 2013. Categories, identities, and cultural classification: Moving beyond a model of categorical constraint. Journal of Management Studies, 50: 1124–1137. Google Scholar
  • Granqvist N., Grodal S., Woolley J. L. 2012. Hedging your bets: Explaining executives’ market labeling strategies in nanotechnology. Organization Science, 24: 395–413. Google Scholar
  • Greenwood R., Raynard M., Kodeih F., Micelotta E. R., Lounsbury M. 2011. Institutional complexity and organizational responses. The Academy of Management Annals, 5: 317–371.LinkGoogle Scholar
  • Greenwood R., Suddaby R., Hinings C. R. 2002. Theorizing change: The role of professional associations in the transformation of institutionalized fields. Academy of Management Journal, 45: 58–80.LinkGoogle Scholar
  • Grimes M. 2010. Strategic sensemaking within funding relationships: The effects of performance measurement on organizational identity in the social sector. Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, 34: 763–783. Google Scholar
  • Grimes M. G., Gehman J., Cao K. 2017. Forthcoming. Positively deviant: Identity work through B Corp certification. Journal of Business Venturing. Google Scholar
  • Grimes M. G., McMullen J. S., Vogus T. J., Miller T. L. 2013. Studying the origins of social entrepreneurship: Compassion and the role of embedded agency. Academy of Management Review, 38: 460–463.LinkGoogle Scholar
  • Guler I., Guillén M. F., Macpherson J. M. 2002. Global competition, institutions, and the diffusion of organizational practices: The international spread of ISO 9000 quality certificates. Administrative Science Quarterly, 47: 207–232. Google Scholar
  • Hannan M. T., Pólos L., Carroll G. 2007. Logics of organization theory: Audiences, codes, and ecologies. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. Google Scholar
  • Hart T. A., Sharfman M. 2015. Assessing the concurrent validity of the revised Kinder, Lydenberg, and Domini corporate social performance indicators. Business & Society, 54: 575–598. Google Scholar
  • Hilbe J. M. 2014. Modeling count data. New York: Cambridge University Press. Google Scholar
  • Honeyman R. 2014. The B Corp handbook. San Francisco, CA: Berrett-Koehler. Google Scholar
  • Hudson B. A., Okhuysen G. A. 2009. Not with a ten-foot pole: Core stigma, stigma transfer, and improbable persistence of men’s bathhouses. Organization Science, 20: 134–153. Google Scholar
  • Hunn E. 1975. A measure of the degree of correspondence of folk to scientific biological classification. American Ethnologist, 2: 309–327. Google Scholar
  • Jay J. 2013. Navigating paradox as a mechanism of change and innovation in hybrid organizations. Academy of Management Journal, 56: 137–159.LinkGoogle Scholar
  • Jennings J. E., Jennings P. D., Greenwood R. 2009. Novelty and new firm performance: The case of employment systems in knowledge-intensive service organizations. Journal of Business Venturing, 24: 338–359. Google Scholar
  • Jones C., Maoret M., Massa F. G., Svejenova S. 2011. Rebels with a cause: Formation, contestation, and expansion of the De Novo category “modern architecture,” 1870–1975. Organization Science, 23: 1523–1545. Google Scholar
  • Kennedy M. T. 2008. Getting counted: Markets, media, and reality. American Sociological Review, 73: 270–295. Google Scholar
  • Kennedy M. T., Lo J., Lounsbury M. 2010. Category currency: The changing value of conformity as a function of ongoing meaning construction. In Hsu G.Negro G.Koçak Ö. (Eds.), Categories in markets: Origins and evolution. Research in the Sociology of Organizations, vol. 31: 369–397. Bingley, UK: Emerald. Google Scholar
  • King A. A., Lenox M. J., Terlaak A. N. N. 2005. The strategic use of decentralized institutions: Exploring certification with the ISO 14001 management standard. Academy of Management Journal, 48: 1091–1106.LinkGoogle Scholar
  • Lakoff G. 1987. Women, fire, and dangerous things: What categories reveal about the mind. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press. Google Scholar
  • Lee M.-D. P., Lounsbury M. 2015. Filtering institutional logics: Community logic variation and differential responses to the institutional complexity of toxic waste. Organization Science, 26: 847–866. Google Scholar
  • Lévinas E. 1999. Alterity and transcendence (M. B. Smith, Tran.). New York: Columbia University Press. Google Scholar
  • Lincoln Y. S., Guba E. G. 1985. Naturalistic inquiry. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage. Google Scholar
  • Lounsbury M. 2007. A tale of two cities: Competing logics and practice variation in the professionalization of mutual funds. Academy of Management Journal, 50: 289–307.LinkGoogle Scholar
  • Lounsbury M., Glynn M. A. 2001. Cultural entrepreneurship: Stories, legitimacy, and the acquisition of resources. Strategic Management Journal, 22: 545–564. Google Scholar
  • Low M. B., Abrahamson E. 1997. Movements, bandwagons, and clones: Industry evolution and the entrepreneurial process. Journal of Business Venturing, 12: 435–457. Google Scholar
  • Markman A. B., Wisniewski E. J. 1997. Similar and different: The differentiation of basic-level categories. Journal of Experimental Psychology. Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 23: 54–70. Google Scholar
  • Marquis C., Davis G. F., Glynn M. A. 2011. Golfing alone? Corporations, elites, and nonprofit growth in 100 American communities. Organization Science, 24: 39–57. Google Scholar
  • Mattingly J. E., Berman S. L. 2006. Measurement of corporate social action: Discovering taxonomy in the Kinder Lydenburg Domini ratings data. Business & Society, 45: 20–46. Google Scholar
  • McKendrick D. G., Jaffee J., Carroll G. R., Khessina O. M. 2003. In the bud? Disk array producers as a (possibly) emergent organizational form. Administrative Science Quarterly, 48: 60–93. Google Scholar
  • Meyer R. E., Höllerer M. A., Jancsary D., van Leeuwen T. 2013. The visual dimension in organizing, organization, and organization research: Core ideas, current developments, and promising avenues. The Academy of Management Annals, 7: 489–555.LinkGoogle Scholar
  • Meyer R. E., Jancsary D., Höllerer M. A., Boxenbaum E. 2017. The role of verbal and visual text in the process of institutionalization. Academy of Management Review, amr.2014.0301. Google Scholar
  • Micelotta E. R., Raynard M. 2011. Concealing or revealing the family? Corporate brand identity strategies in family firms. Family Business Review, 24: 197–216. Google Scholar
  • Miles M. B., Huberman A. M. 1994. Qualitative data analysis (2nd edn). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Google Scholar
  • Miller T. L., Grimes M. G., McMullen J. S., Vogus T. J. 2012. Venturing for others with heart and head: How compassion encourages social entrepreneurship. Academy of Management Review, 37: 616–fdff 640.LinkGoogle Scholar
  • MSCI 2015. MSCI ESG KLD STATS: 1991–2014 data sets. MSCI, New York. Google Scholar
  • Navis C., Glynn M. A. 2010. How new market categories emerge: Temporal dynamics of legitimacy, identity, and entrepreneurship in satellite radio, 1990-2005. Administrative Science Quarterly, 55: 439–471. Google Scholar
  • Navis C., Glynn M. A. 2011. Legitimate distinctiveness and the entrepreneurial identity: Influence on investor judgments of new venture plausibility. Academy of Management Review, 36: 479–499.LinkGoogle Scholar
  • Negro G., Hannan M. T., Rao H. 2010. Categorical contrast and audience appeal: Niche width and critical success in winemaking. Industrial and Corporate Change, 19: 1397–1425. Google Scholar
  • Paolella L., Durand R. 2016. Category spanning, evaluation, and performance: Revised theory and test on the corporate law market. Academy of Management Journal, 59: 330–351.LinkGoogle Scholar
  • Patton M. Q. 2002. Qualitative research and evaluation methods (3rd edn). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Google Scholar
  • Phillips N., Oswick C. 2012. Organizational discourse: Domains, debates, and directions. The Academy of Management Annals, 6: 435–481.LinkGoogle Scholar
  • Pollock T. G., Gulati R. 2007. Standing out from the crowd: The visibility enhancing effects of IPO related signals on alliance formation by entrepreneurial firms. Strategic Organization, 5: 339–372. Google Scholar
  • Pontikes E. G. 2012. Two sides of the same coin how ambiguous classification affects multiple audiences’ evaluations. Administrative Science Quarterly, 57: 81–118. Google Scholar
  • Pontikes E. G., Barnett W. P. 2015. The persistence of lenient market categories. Organization Science, 26: 1415–1431. Google Scholar
  • Porac J. F., Thomas H., Baden-Fuller C. 2011. Competitive groups as cognitive communities: The case of Scottish knitwear manufacturers revisited. Journal of Management Studies, 48: 646–664. Google Scholar
  • Porac J. F., Wade J. B., Pollock T. G. 1999. Industry categories and the politics of the comparable firm in CEO compensation. Administrative Science Quarterly, 44: 112–144. Google Scholar
  • Raffaelli R., Glynn M. A. 2014. Turnkey or tailored? Relational pluralism, institutional complexity, and the organizational adoption of more or less customized practices. Academy of Management Journal, 57: 541–562.LinkGoogle Scholar
  • Raftery A. E. 1995. Bayesian model selection in social research. Sociological Methodology, 25: 111–163. Google Scholar
  • Rao H. 1994. The social construction of reputation: Certification contests, legitimation, and the survival of organizations in the American automobile industry: 1895–1912. Strategic Management Journal, 15(S1): 29–44. Google Scholar
  • Reinecke J., Ansari S. 2015. What is a “fair” price? Ethics as sensemaking. Organization Science, 26: 867–888. Google Scholar
  • Ricker-Gilbert J., Jayne T. S., Chirwa E. 2011. Subsidies and crowding out: A double-hurdle model of fertilizer demand in Malawi. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 93: 26–42. Google Scholar
  • Rindova V. P., Petkova A. P., Kotha S. 2007. Standing out: How new firms in emerging markets build reputation. Strategic Organization, 5: 31–70. Google Scholar
  • Rindova V. P., Williamson I. O., Petkova A. P., Sever J. M. 2005. Being good or being known: An empirical examination of the dimensions, antecedents, and consequences of organizational reputation. Academy of Management Journal, 48: 1033–1049.LinkGoogle Scholar
  • Rosch E., Simpson C., Miller R. S. 1976. Structural bases of typicality effects. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 2: 491–502. Google Scholar
  • Ruef M., Patterson K. 2009. Credit and classification: The impact of industry boundaries in nineteenth-century America. Administrative Science Quarterly, 54: 486–520. Google Scholar
  • Sahlin K., Wedlin L. 2008. Circulating ideas: Imitation, translation and editing. In R. Greenwood, C. Oliver, R. Suddaby, & K. Sahlin (Eds.), The Sage handbook of organizational institutionalism: 218–242. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Google Scholar
  • Selznick P. 1957. Leadership in administration. New York: Harper & Row. Google Scholar
  • Sine W. D., David R. J., Mitsuhashi H. 2007. From plan to plant: Effects of certification on operational start-up in the emergent independent power sector. Organization Science, 18: 578–594. Google Scholar
  • Singer J. D., Willett J. B. 2003. Applied longitudinal data analysis. New York: Oxford University Press. Google Scholar
  • Swidler A. 1986. Culture in action: Symbols and strategies. American Sociological Review, 51: 273–286. Google Scholar
  • Terlaak A., King A. A. 2006. The effect of certification with the ISO 9000 Quality Management Standard: A signaling approach. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 60: 579–602. Google Scholar
  • Vergne J.-P. 2012. Stigmatized categories and public disapproval of organizations: A mixed-methods study of the global arms industry, 1996–2007. Academy of Management Journal, 55: 1027–1052.LinkGoogle Scholar
  • Vergne J.-P., Wry T. 2014. Categorizing categorization research: Review, integration, and future directions. Journal of Management Studies, 51: 56–94. Google Scholar
  • Waddock S. A., Graves S. B. 1997. The corporate social performance–financial performance link. Strategic Management Journal, 18: 303–319. Google Scholar
  • Wade J. B., Porac J. F., Pollock T. G., Graffin S. D. 2006. The burden of celebrity: The impact of CEO certification contests on CEO pay and performance. Academy of Management Journal, 49: 643–660.LinkGoogle Scholar
  • Weber K., Heinze K. L., DeSoucey M. 2008. Forage for thought: Mobilizing codes in the movement for grass-fed meat and dairy products. Administrative Science Quarterly, 53: 529–567. Google Scholar
  • Wright A. L., Zammuto R. F., Liesch P. W. 2017. Maintaining the values of a profession: Institutional work and moral emotions in the emergency department. Academy of Management Journal, 60: 200–237.LinkGoogle Scholar
  • Wry T., Lounsbury M., Glynn M. A. 2011. Legitimating nascent collective identities: Coordinating cultural entrepreneurship. Organization Science, 22: 449–463. Google Scholar
  • Wry T., Lounsbury M., Jennings P. D. 2014. Hybrid vigor: Securing venture capital by spanning categories in nanotechnology. Academy of Management Journal, 57: 1309–1333.LinkGoogle Scholar
  • Wry T., York J. G. 2017. An identity-based approach to social enterprise. Academy of Management Review, 42: 437–460.LinkGoogle Scholar
  • York J. G., Hargrave T. J., Pacheco D. F. 2016. Converging winds: Logic hybridization in the Colorado wind energy field. Academy of Management Journal, 59: 579–610.LinkGoogle Scholar
  • Zhao E. Y., Fisher G., Lounsbury M., Miller D. 2017. Optimal distinctiveness: Broadening the interface between institutional theory and strategic management. Strategic Management Journal, 38: 93–113. Google Scholar
  • Zuckerman E. W. 1999. The categorical imperative: Securities analysts and the illegitimacy discount. American Journal of Sociology, 104: 1398–1438. Google Scholar
Academy of Management
  Academy of Management
  100 Summit Lake Drive, Suite 110
  Valhalla, NY 10595, USA
  Phone: +1 (914) 326-1800
  Fax: +1 (914) 326-1900