Abstract
We develop and test a theory of how unintended audiences create reaction costs for firms that use corporate social responsibility (CSR) as a signal. We introduce and define reaction costs as costs that signal senders incur when unintended audiences react negatively to a true signal that was intended for another audience. We argue that activist hedge funds—an unintended audience—treat CSR as a signal that firms have wasteful intentions and capabilities, which prevent firms from maximizing shareholder value in the short term. On that basis, we hypothesize that activist hedge funds are more likely to target firms with higher levels of CSR, thus imposing reaction costs on these firms. We further argue that this relationship is weaker when firms operate in industries with high levels of CSR, and stronger when firms’ financial communication is vague. Using data on activist hedge fund campaigns in the U.S. between 2000 and 2016, we find supporting results. Our study shows that CSR signals may be costlier than previously assumed and contributes to research on CSR, signaling, and corporate governance.
REFERENCES
Activist Insight. 2017, September. Payday. Activist Insight Monthly, 6: 5–7. Retrieved from www.activistinsight.com/amp/issues/AiM0917_070917101104.pdf Google Scholar- 2015. Connecting the dots: Bringing external corporate governance into the corporate governance puzzle. Academy of Management Annals, 9: 483–573.Link , Google Scholar
- 2021. Activist hedge funds: Beware the new titans. Academy of Management Perspectives, 35: 96–122.Link , Google Scholar
- 2017. Masters of disasters? An empirical analysis of how societies benefit from corporate disaster aid. Academy of Management Journal, 60: 1682–1708.Link , Google Scholar
- 2014. Business sustainability: It is about time. Strategic Organization, 12: 70–78. Google Scholar
- 2007. Stakeholder influence capacity and the variability of financial returns to corporate social responsibility. Academy of Management Review, 32: 794–816.Link , Google Scholar
- 2008. Controlling for endogeneity with instrumental variables in strategic management research. Strategic Organization, 6: 285–327. Google Scholar
- 2015. The long-term effects of hedge funds activism. Columbia Law Review, 115: 1085–1155. Google Scholar
- 2018, October 30. Estimating grouped data models with a binary dependent variable and fixed effects: What are the issues (Working paper). Retrieved from https://arxiv.org/pdf/1810.12105.pdf Google Scholar
- 2014. Signalling theory and equilibrium in strategic management research: An assessment and a research agenda. Journal of Management Studies, 51: 1334–1360. Google Scholar
- 2019. Information asymmetry in management research: Past accomplishments and future opportunities. Journal of Management, 45: 122–158. Google Scholar
- 1988. Implementing entrepreneurial ideas: The case for intention. Academy of Management Review, 13: 442–453.Link , Google Scholar
- 2017. Activism mergers. Journal of Financial Economics, 126: 54–73. Google Scholar
- 2011. Corporate governance and hedge fund activism. Review of Derivatives Research, 14: 169–204. Google Scholar
- 2010. Hedge fund activism: A review. Foundations and Trends in Finance, 4: 185–246. Google Scholar
- 2008. Hedge fund activism, corporate governance, and firm performance. Journal of Finance, 63: 1729–1775. Google Scholar
- 2017. Heterogeneous social motives and interactions: The three predictable paths of capability development. Strategic Management Journal, 38: 1755–1773. Google Scholar
- 2014. CEO ideology as an element of the corporate opportunity structure for social activists. Academy of Management Journal, 57: 1786–1809.Link , Google Scholar
- 2016. Social activism in and around organizations. Academy of Management Annals, 10: 671–727.Link , Google Scholar
- 1998. Investors on myopic R&D investment behavior. Accounting Review, 73: 305–333. Google Scholar
- 2018. Strategic silence: Withholding certification status as a hypocrisy avoidance tactic. Administrative Science Quarterly, 63: 130–169. Google Scholar
- 2018. Activist-impelled divestitures and shareholder value. Strategic Management Journal, 39: 2726–2744. Google Scholar
- 2008. Value creation or destruction? Hedge funds as shareholder activists. Journal of Corporate Finance, 14: 323–336. Google Scholar
- 2016. The wolf at the door: The impact of hedge fund activism on corporate governance. Annals of Corporate Governance, 1: 1–94. Google Scholar
- 2011. Signaling theory: A review and assessment. Journal of Management, 37: 39–67. Google Scholar
- 2016. Industry-specific CSR: Analysis of 20 years of research. European Business Review, 28: 250–273. Google Scholar
- 2018. Quitting when the going gets tough: A downside of high performance expectations. Academy of Management Journal, 61: 1667–1691.Link , Google Scholar
- 2003. Corporate governance: Decades of dialogue and data. Academy of Management Review, 28: 371–382.Link , Google Scholar
- 2006. Predicting the cost of environmental management system adoption: The role of capabilities, resources and ownership structure. Strategic Management Journal, 27: 301–320. Google Scholar
- 2007. Ideologically motivated activism: How activist groups influence corporate social change activities. Academy of Management Review, 32: 901–924.Link , Google Scholar
- 2017. Thirty years of shareholder activism: A survey of empirical research. Journal of Corporate Finance, 44: 405–424. Google Scholar
- 2019. One step forward, two steps back: How external evaluations can shorten organizational time horizons. Organization Science, 30: 761–780. Google Scholar
- 2019. Bouncing back: Building resilience through social and environmental practices in the context of the 2008 global financial crisis. Journal of Management, 45: 1434–1460. Google Scholar
- 2020. Disentangling the effects of hedge fund activism on firm financial and social performance. Strategic Management Journal, 41: 1054–1082. Google Scholar
- 2021. How temporal focus shapes the influence of executive compensation on risk taking. Academy of Management Journal, 64: 1–28. Google Scholar
- 2019. Willing and able: A general model of organizational responses to normative pressures. Academy of Management Review, 44: 299–320.Link , Google Scholar
- 2019. Do investors actually value sustainability indices? Replication, development, and new evidence on CSR visibility. Strategic Management Journal, 40: 1471–1490. Google Scholar
- 2014. Endogenous selection bias: The problem of conditioning on a collider variable. Annual Review of Sociology, 40: 31–53. Google Scholar
- 2019. Social media and the formation of organizational reputation. Academy of Management Review, 44: 28–52.Link , Google Scholar
- 2006. The symbolic management of strategic change: Sensegiving via framing and decoupling. Academy of Management Journal, 49: 1173–1193.Link , Google Scholar
- 2013. Corporate social responsibility and shareholder reaction: The environmental awareness of investors. Academy of Management Journal, 56: 758–781.Link , Google Scholar
- 2018. Competing for government procurement contracts: The role of corporate social responsibility. Strategic Management Journal, 39: 1299–1324. Google Scholar
- 2013. The costs of shareholder activism: Evidence from a sequential decision model. Journal of Financial Economics, 107: 610–631. Google Scholar
- 2005. The relationship between corporate philanthropy and shareholder wealth: A risk management perspective. Academy of Management Review, 30: 777–798.Link , Google Scholar
- 2014. Shareholder activism: A multidisciplinary review. Journal of Management, 40: 1230–1268. Google Scholar
- 2020. Rivals’ negative earnings surprises, language signals, and firms’ competitive actions. Academy of Management Journal, 63: 637–659.Link , Google Scholar
- 2017. Language and competition: Communication vagueness, interpretation difficulties, and market entry. Academy of Management Journal, 60: 2073–2098.Link , Google Scholar
- 2018. Do women CEOs face greater threat of shareholder activism compared to male CEOs? A role congruity perspective. Journal of Applied Psychology, 103: 228–236. Google Scholar
- 2019. The business case for CSR: A trump card against hypocrisy? Journal of Business Research. Published online ahead of print. doi: 10.1016/j.jbusres.2019.08.043 Google Scholar
- 2019. Communication vagueness dictionary (WordStat version 8). Montreal, Quebec: Provalis Research. Google Scholar
- 1969. Opinionation, vagueness, and specificity-distinctions: Essay traits measured by computer. American Educational Research Journal, 6: 271–286. Google Scholar
- 2007. The use of logit and probit models in strategic management research: Critical issues. Strategic Management Journal, 28: 331–343. Google Scholar
- 2008.
Financial communication . In W. Donsbach (Ed.), The international encyclopedia of communication: 1–5. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley. Google Scholar - 2015. The impact of corporate social responsibility on investment recommendations: Analysts’ perceptions and shifting institutional logics. Strategic Management Journal, 36: 1053–1081. Google Scholar
- 2003. Signaling through private equity placements and its impact on the valuation of biotechnology firms. Journal of Business Venturing, 18: 361–380. Google Scholar
- 2011. Corporate social responsibility: The role of fortune 100 companies in domestic and international natural disasters. Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management, 18: 352–369. Google Scholar
- 2002. Searching for a corporate savior: The irrational quest for charismatic CEOs. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. Google Scholar
- 2005. The strategic use of decentralized institutions: Exploring certification with the ISO 14001 management standard. Academy of Management Journal, 48: 1091–1106.Link , Google Scholar
- 2009. Entrepreneurial shareholder activism: Hedge funds and other private investors. Journal of Finance, 64: 187–229. Google Scholar
- 2011. The impact of hedge fund activism on the target firm’s existing bondholders. Review of Financial Studies, 24: 1735–1771. Google Scholar
- 2019. Signaling legitimacy across institutional contexts—The intermediary role of corporate social responsibility rating agencies. Global Strategy Journal. Published online ahead of print. doi: 10.1002/gsj.1355 Google Scholar
- 2018, August 27. Paul Singer, doomsday investor. New Yorker. Retrieved from www.newyorker.com/magazine/2018/08/27/paul-singer-doomsday-investor Google Scholar
Lazard . 2020, January 20. Lazard’s 2019 review of shareholder activism. Retrieved from https://www.lazard.com/perspective/lazards-2019-annual-review-of-shareholder-activism Google Scholar- 2018. Winning us with trifles: Adverse selection in the use of philanthropy as insurance. Strategic Management Journal, 39: 2591–2617. Google Scholar
- 2014. Cleaning house or jumping ship? Understanding board upheaval following financial fraud. Strategic Management Journal, 35: 926–937. Google Scholar
- 2018. When do theories become self-fulfilling? Exploring the boundary conditions of performativity. Academy of Management Review, 43: 487–508.Link , Google Scholar
- 2011. What makes conference calls useful? The information content of managers’ presentations and analysts’ discussion sessions. Accounting Review, 86: 1383–1414. Google Scholar
- 2006. Measurement of corporate social action discovering taxonomy in the Kinder Lydenburg Domini ratings data. Business & Society, 45: 20–46. Google Scholar
- 2006. How to build reputation in financial markets. Long Range Planning, 39: 385–407. Google Scholar
- 2019. Take a stand or keep your seat: Board turnover after social movement boycotts. Academy of Management Journal, 63: 1028–1053. Google Scholar
- 2014. Activism for corporate responsibility: Conceptualizing private regulation opportunity structures. Journal of Management Studies, 51: 1091–1117. Google Scholar
- 2009. Demographic diversity in the boardroom: Mediators of the board diversity–firm performance relationship. Journal of Management Studies, 46: 755–786. Google Scholar
- 2012. Using private management standard certification to reduce information asymmetries in corrupt environments. Strategic Management Journal, 33: 1103–1113. Google Scholar
MSCI . 2015, June. MSCI ESG KLD Stats: 1991–2014 data sets. Retrieved from https://www.wiso.uni-hamburg.de/bibliothek/recherche/datenbanken/unternehmensdaten/msci-methodology-2014.pdf Google Scholar- 2011. Doing good deeds in times of need: A strategic perspective on corporate disaster donations. Strategic Management Journal, 32: 911–929. Google Scholar
- 2017, October 11. P&G says Nelson Peltz has lost battle for board seat. Financial Times. Retrieved from www.ft.com/content/bf804304-adcd-11e7-aab9-abaa44b1e130 Google Scholar
- 2014. Liquidity and shareholder activism. Review of Financial Studies, 28: 486–520. Google Scholar
- 1997. Toward an attention-based view of the firm. Strategic Management Journal, 18(S1): 187–206. Google Scholar
- 2020. Salient expectations? Incongruence across capability and integrity signals and investor reactions to organizational misconduct. Academy of Management Journal. Published online ahead of print. doi: 10.5465/amj.2018.0698 Google Scholar
- 2016. Corporate social responsibility or CEO narcissism? CSR motivations and organizational performance. Strategic Management Journal, 37: 262–279. Google Scholar
- 2011. The impact of norm-conforming behaviors on firm reputation. Strategic Management Journal, 32: 969–993. Google Scholar
- 2011. Geographic distance and corporate acquisitions: Signals from IPO firms. Strategic Management Journal, 32: 876–894. Google Scholar
- 2010. Gender, mentoring, and career success: The importance of organizational context. Personnel Psychology, 63: 385–405. Google Scholar
- 2016. Time horizon of investments in the resource allocation process: Review and framework for next steps. Journal of Management, 42: 1169–1194. Google Scholar
- 2018. Geographic co-location of partners and rivals: Implications for the design of R&D alliances. Academy of Management Journal, 61: 945–965.Link , Google Scholar
- 2013. Democratizing corporate governance: Compensating for the democratic deficit of corporate political activity and corporate citizenship. Business & Society, 52: 473–514. Google Scholar
- 2014. The perils of endogeneity and instrumental variables in strategy research: Understanding through simulations. Strategic Management Journal, 35: 1070–1079. Google Scholar
- 2021. Portfolio spillover of institutional investor activism: An awareness-motivation-capability perspective. Academy of Management Journal, 63: 1865–1892. Google Scholar
- Shi W. & DesJardine M. R. In press. Under attack! CEO implicit motives and firm competitive responses following short seller activism. Organization Science. Google Scholar
- 2017. Does engagement in corporate social responsibility provide strategic insurance-like effects? Strategic Management Journal, 38: 455–470. Google Scholar
- 1947. Administrative behavior: A study of decision-making processes in administrative organization. New York, NY: Macmillan. Google Scholar
- 2015. Short on time: Intertemporal tensions in business sustainability. Organization Science, 26: 531–549. Google Scholar
- 2016. A behavioral understanding of investment horizon and firm performance. Organization Science, 27: 1202–1218. Google Scholar
- 1973. Job market signaling. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 87: 355–374. Google Scholar
- 2000. The contributions of the economics of information to twentieth century economics. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 115: 1441–1478. Google Scholar
- 2005.
Testing for weak instruments in linear IV regression . In D. W. K. AndrewsJ. H. Stock, & T. J. Rothenberg (Eds.), Identification and inference for econometric models: Essays in honor of Thomas Rothenberg: 80–108. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press. Google Scholar - 2016. The signaling effect of corporate social responsibility in emerging economies. Journal of Business Ethics, 134: 479–491. Google Scholar
- 1997. Dynamic capabilities and strategic management. Strategic Management Journal, 18: 509–533. Google Scholar
Thomson Reuters . 2019. Thomson Reuters ESG scores [Indices]. Retrieved from https://www.refinitiv.com/content/dam/marketing/en_us/docu-ments/methodology/esg-scores-methodology.pdf Google Scholar- 1997. Corporate social performance and organizational attractiveness to prospective employees. Academy of Management Journal, 40: 658–672.Link , Google Scholar
- 2018. Signal incongruence and its consequences: A study of media disapproval and CEO overcompensation. Organization Science, 29: 796–817. Google Scholar
- 2012. Corporate governance and environmental performance: Is there really a link? Strategic Management Journal, 33: 885–913. Google Scholar
- 2010. Econometric analysis of cross section and panel data. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Google Scholar
- 2015, January. The activist revolution: Understanding and navigating a new world of heightened investor scrutiny. Retrieved from https://www.jpmorgan.com/content/dam/jpm/corporate/investment-bank/cfa/pub/Understanding_and_Navigating_a_New_World_of_Heightened_Investor_Scrutiny.pdf Google Scholar