Skip main navigation
Articles

Do Business School Professors Make Good Executive Managers?

    Published Online:1 Aug 2007https://doi.org/10.5465/amp.2007.26421237

    Abstract

    Despite suggestions that business school professors do not understand what actually accounts for the performance of business organizations, the evidence is anecdotal at best. We review past work, develop expectations, and provide large-scale evidence for examining the validity of such suggestions. We accessed extensive data provided by Dun & Bradstreet and procured detailed information from 765 leading public and private North American businesses. Analysis of 215 closely matched pairs showed that companies with former business school professors as executives generated significantly greater revenues per employee than counterparts with non-former professors as executives. Companies with former professors in vice-president positions had the best performance in the sample, signifying the value of correspondence between academic expertise and functional business area. Companies with executives who had exited academic careers early performed better than companies with late career exit counterparts. The performance of companies with executives who were professors at top-ranked business schools was the same as other companies with executives who were professors at non-ranked business schools. We observed controls to mitigate effects from organization size, industry sector, and geographic location and executed several auxiliary analyses to assess the validity of principal findings. Finally, we interviewed a sub-sample of executive manager participants by telephone and collected qualitative data from them via surveys to further interpret the results and diminish alternative explanations. Our findings suggest that the fashionable idea that business school professors are unable to “walk the walk” is a popular myth.

    References

    • Abrahamson E. (1996). Management fashion. Academy of Management Review, 21, 254–285.Link , Google Scholar
    • Andrews K. R. (1968). Introduction to the 30th anniversary edition of The functions of the executive. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Google Scholar
    • Argyris C. (1964). Integrating the individual and the organization. New York, NY: John Wiley and Sons. Google Scholar
    • Armstrong S. (2005). Postgraduate management education in the UK: Lessons from or lessons for the US model? Academy of Management Learning and Education, 4(2), 229–234.Abstract , Google Scholar
    • Bailey E. E. , Helfat C. E. (2003). External management succession, human capital, and firm performance: An integrative analysis. Managerial and Decision Economics, 24, 347–369. Google Scholar
    • Barber B. M. , Lyon J. D. (1996). Detecting abnormal operating performance: The empirical power and specification of test statistics. Journal of Financial Economics, 41 (3), 359–399 Google Scholar
    • Barnard C. (1938). The functions of the executive. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Google Scholar
    • Barrick M. R. , Mount M. K. (1991). The Big Five personality dimensions and job performance: A metaanalysis. Personnel Psychology, 44, 1–26. Google Scholar
    • Baumol W. J. (1997). Formal entrepreneurship theory in economics: Existence and bounds. Journal of Business Venturing, 8, 197–210. Google Scholar
    • Bendixen M. T. (1995). Compositional perceptual mapping using chi-squared trees analysis and correspondence analysis. Journal of Marketing Management, 11, 571–581. Google Scholar
    • Bennis W. , O'Toole J. (2005). How business schools lost their way. Harvard Business Review, 83(5), 96–104. Google Scholar
    • Cappelli P. (2005). The path to the top: Changes in the attributes and careers of corporate executives, 1980 to 2001. Harvard Business Review, 83(1), 25–32. Google Scholar
    • Cascio W. F. , Young C. E. , Morris J. R. (1997). Financial consequences of employment-change decisions in major US corporations. Academy of Management Journal, 40(5), 1175–1189.Abstract , Google Scholar
    • Danko J. M. , Anderson B. L. (2005). In defense of the MBA. BizEd, (November/December), 24–28. Google Scholar
    • Denis D. J. , Denis D. K. (1993). Managerial discretion, organization structure, and corporate performance: A study of leveraged recapitalizations. Journal of Accounting Economics, 16, 209–236. Google Scholar
    • DiMaggio P. J. , Powell W. W. (1983). The iron cage revisited: Institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organizational fields. American Sociological Review, 48, 147–160. Google Scholar
    • Dowling W. F. (1978). Conversation: an interview with Fletcher Byrom. Organizational Dynamics, 7, 41. Google Scholar
    • Finkelstein S. , Hambrick D. C. (1996). Strategic leadership: Top executives and their effects on organizations. Minneapolis/St. Paul, MN: West Publishing Company. Google Scholar
    • Ghoshal S. (2005). Bad management theories are destroying good management practices. Academy of Management Learning and Education, (4)1, 75–91. Google Scholar
    • Gist M. E. (1997). Getting tenure. In Frost P.Susan Taylor M. (Eds.), Rhythms of academic life: Personal accounts of careers in academia (pp. 185–192). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications. Google Scholar
    • Greenacre M. J. (1984). Theory and application of correspondence analysis. London: Academic Press. Google Scholar
    • Gunz H. , Jalland R. , Evans M. (1998). New strategy, wrong managers? What you need to know about career streams. Academy of Management Executive, (12)2, 21–37. Google Scholar
    • Hair J. F. , Anderson R. E. , Tatham R. L. , Black W. C. (1992). Multivariate data analysis, (3rd Ed.). New York, NY: Macmillan Publishing Company. Google Scholar
    • Hambrick D. C. (2007). Upper echelons theory: An update. Academy of Management Review, 32(2), 334–343.Link , Google Scholar
    • Hambrick D. C. , Mason P. A. (1984). Upper echelons: The organization as a reflection of its top managers. Academy of Management Review, 16, 719–742. Google Scholar
    • Hannan M. T. , Freeman J. (1977). The population ecology of organizations. American Journal of Sociology, 82(5), 929–964. Google Scholar
    • Hays W. L. (1994). Statistics (5th Ed.). Fort Worth, TX: Harcourt Brace College Publishers. Google Scholar
    • Helfat C. E. , Harris D. , Wolfson P. J. (2006). The pipeline to the top: Women and men in the top executive ranks of U.S. corporations. Academy of Management Perspectives, 20(4), 42–64.Abstract , Google Scholar
    • Hendricks K. B. , Singhal V. R. (2001). Firm characteristics, total quality management, and financial performance. Journal of Operations Management, 19(3), 269–1285. Google Scholar
    • Hogan R. , Warrenfeltz R. (2003). Educating the modern manager. Academy of Management Learning and Education, 2(1), 74–84.Abstract , Google Scholar
    • House R. J. , Javidan M. , Dorfman P. W. , de Luque M. S. (2006). A failure of scholarship: Graen's critique of GLOBE. Academy of Management Perspectives, 20(4), 102–114. Google Scholar
    • Jones D. (2005, April 7). Wanted: CEO, no Ivy required: Fewer of today's CEOs come from Ivy League schools. USA Today, p. 1A. Google Scholar
    • Lindsay E. , Homes V. , McCall M. W.. (1987). Key events in executives' lives, technical report no. 32. Greensboro, NC: Center for Creative Leadership. Google Scholar
    • Lowe K. B. (1998). Downsizing and firm performance: Panacea or paradise lost? Academy of Management Executive, 12(4), 130–131.Abstract , Google Scholar
    • Lundholm R. , Sloan R. (2004). Equity valuation and analysis. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill/Irwin. Google Scholar
    • Mailer N. K. (2004). The spooky art: Some thoughts on writing [First Trade Paperback Edition]. New York, NY: Random House. Google Scholar
    • Mintzberg H. , Gosling J. R. (2002). Reality programming for MBAs. Strategy and Business, 26(1), 28–31. Google Scholar
    • Mintzberg H. , Lampel J. (2001, February 19). Matter of degrees: Do MBAs make better CEOs? Fortune, p. 244. Google Scholar
    • Moffitt N. (2004). The path to the top: Wharton's Peter Cappelli recounts the history of executive careers and the creation of the fast track. Wharton Alumni Magazine (spring), 24–28. Google Scholar
    • Murphy K. R. (1996). Getting published. In Frost P.Susan Taylor M. (Eds.), Rhythms of academic life: Personal accounts of careers in academia (pp. 129–134). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications. Google Scholar
    • Pfeffer J. , Fong C. (2002). The end of business schools? Less success than meets the eye. Academy of Management Learning and Education, 1 (1), 1–17. Google Scholar
    • Rynes S. , Bartunek J. , Daft R. (2001). Across the great divide: Knowledge creation and transfer between practitioners and academics. Academy of Management Journal, 44(2), 340–355.Link , Google Scholar
    • Rynes S. , Hillman A. , Ireland R. D. , Kirkman B. , Law K. , Miller C. C. , Rajagopalan N. , Shapiro D. (2005). From the editors: Everything you've always wanted to know about AMJ (but may have been afraid to ask). Academy of Management Journal, 48(5), 732–737.Abstract , Google Scholar
    • Schmidt F. , Hunter J. , Caplan J. (1981). Validity generalization results for two job groups in the petroleum industry. Journal of Applied Psychology, 66(3), 261–273. Google Scholar
    • Shane S. (2004). Academic entrepreneurship: University spinoffs and wealth creation. Aldershot, UK: Edward Elgar. Google Scholar
    • Stehl C. , Smith D. , Omura O. (1990). After the merger: Should executives stay or go? Academy of Management Executive, 4(1), 50–60. Google Scholar
    • Tabachnik B. G. , Fidell L. S. (1996). Using multivariate statistics (3rd ed.). New York, NY: HarperCollins College Publishers. Google Scholar
    • Tett R. P. , Guterman H. A. , Bleier A. , Murphy P. J. (2000). Development and content validation of a hyperdimensional taxonomy of managerial competence. Human Performance, 13(3), 205–251. Google Scholar
    • Tett R. , Jackson D. , Rothstein M. (1991). Personality measures as predictors of job performance: A meta-analytic review. Personnel Psychology, 44(4), 703–742. Google Scholar
    • Underhill L. G. , Peisach M. (1985). Correspondence analysis and its application in multi-elemental trace analysis. Trace and Microprobe Techniques, 3(1, 2), 41–65. Google Scholar
    • Van De Ven A. H. , Johnson P. E. (2006). Knowledge for theory and practice. Academy of Management Review, 31(4), 802–821.Link , Google Scholar
    • Vermeulen F. (2005). On rigor and relevance: Fostering dialectic process in management research. Academy of Management Journal, 48(6), 978–982.Abstract , Google Scholar
    • Von Glinow M. A. (1997). Working as a consultant: Academic imprimatur or taboo? In Frost P.Susan Taylor M. (Eds.), Rhythms of academic life: Personal accounts of careers in academia (pp. 371–379). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications. Google Scholar
    Academy of Management
      Academy of Management
      100 Summit Lake Drive, Suite 110
      Valhalla, NY 10595, USA
      Phone: +1 (914) 326-1800
      Fax: +1 (914) 326-1900
    © 2025 Academy of Management
    Powered by Atypon® Literatum